Rope Climbs vs Pull-Ups (Full Comparison)

When it comes to building upper body strength and improving athletic performance, two exercises that can be extremely effective are Rope Climbs and Pull-ups.

Both exercises require a significant amount of upper body and grip strength, but there are some key differences between the two that might make one more suitable for certain individuals or goals.

Rope Climbs involve scaling a vertical rope using both the arms and legs. This exercise works the back, biceps, forearms, and grip strength, and requires significant coordination and endurance. Pull-ups, on the other hand, work many of the same muscle groups but require less technique and coordination.

I’ve been a College Strength Coach for 20 years and in this article, I’m going to compare and contrast these two exercises – benefits, pros, cons, etc – so you can get a better idea of which exercise might fit best for you and your training goals.

Rope Climbs

Equipment Needed

• Climbing Rope
• Anchor Point (from ceiling or tall object)

Step-by-Step Instructions

• Make sure the rope you’re using is sturdy and thick enough to support your weight. It should also be long enough to reach the height you want to climb.
• Start by standing facing the rope and grip it with both hands, one hand slightly above the other.
• Place one foot on the rope, and use it to help you push off the ground and create tension on the rope. As you do this, pull yourself up using your arms and upper body strength.
• To maintain your balance and control, keep your hips as close to the rope as possible. This will also help you use your legs to push off and climb more efficiently.
• Rope climbing requires coordination between your upper and lower body. Use your arms to pull yourself up while using your legs to push off the rope and create upward momentum.
• Keep climbing until you reach the top of the rope. When you’re ready to come down, slowly lower yourself back down the rope using your arms and legs in a controlled descent.
• Consider wearing gloves to protect your hands, and make sure there is a soft surface to land on if you fall. It’s also a good idea to have a spotter or partner to assist you and ensure your safety.

Coaching Points

One of the most important aspects of rope climbing is having a strong and secure grip. Use chalk or other grip aids to help you maintain your grip and prevent slipping.

Rope Climbs requires a lot of upper body strength, but don’t forget to engage your core muscles as well. This will help you maintain your balance and stability on the rope. Keep your hips close to the rope and use your core muscles to help lift your legs and maintain proper form as you climb.

Rope climbing is a challenging exercise that requires both physical strength and technique. To improve your rope climbing skills, it’s important to practice regularly. Set aside time to work on your technique and gradually increase the height and difficulty of your climbs.

Don’t have a rope to climb? Here are 10 Rope Climb alternatives that don’t need one.

Benefits of Rope Climbing

Rope climbing is a full-body exercise that primarily targets the upper body, including the back, shoulders, arms, and core. Regular rope climbing can help build strength in these muscles, leading to improved overall upper-body strength and endurance.

Grip strength is a crucial component of rope climbing, and regular climbing can help improve your grip strength over time. This can translate to improved performance in other exercises and activities that require grip strength, such as weightlifting or rock climbing.

Rope climbing requires coordination between the upper and lower body, as well as balance and stability on the rope.

Rope climbing is a challenging exercise that requires focus, determination, and mental toughness. Regular practice can help build mental resilience and confidence, which can carry over to other areas of your life.

Pull-Ups

Equipment Needed

• Pull Up Bar (Either as part of a rack or a wall-mounted bar)

Optional Equipment

• Weight belt (For weighted variations)
• Resistance Band (To assist in completing the pull-up or doing more repetitions with full range of motion)

Step-by-Step Instruction

• Approach the pull-up bar and grab the bar with a pronated grip (palms facing away).
• Use a bench to get to the bar if it is too high.
• Later in the article, I will talk about variations, alternatives, and modifications where the supinated (palms facing in) grip will be discussed.
• Squeeze the bar and engage the core muscles and do not cross your legs.
• Engage the upper back and pull up until your chin is over the bar.
• Pause for 1 second with your chin over the bar.
• Slowly lower yourself back to the starting position.

Coaching Points

Take your time and master the Pull-up. The benefits of doing sound pull-ups will pay dividends for your shoulder health and the potential to maximize your upper body strength.

I would highly recommend this movement to any lifter or athlete. It provides all the benefits of an upper-body pulling movement with little to no risk.

Common Mistakes

By far the biggest mistake I see in the pull-up is lifters not using a full range of motion. Hang all the way down and maintain great tension through the shoulders and abdomen (DO NOT JUST HANG IN THE BOTTOM). Pull all the way up and do not whip your head so that your chin barely makes it over the bar.

As with any exercise, do not sacrifice form for the completion or more weight.

Another mistake is lifters go too fast with their pull-ups. Pull-ups are commonly programmed for strength and hypertrophy. This means time under tension is key. Take them slow and perfect the movement to yield maximal results.

Rope Climbs vs Pull-Ups: Which is Better?

Now, let’s do a side-by-side comparison and discuss if one of these exercises is better than the other for some common lifting goals.

Better For Developing Strength: Toss Up

It’s hard to say which exercise is truly better for developing strength as both movements have their pros and cons.

Rope Climbs are more of a total body exercise. In addition to developing back, bicep and grip strength, Rope Climbs also do a great job at working the core and even incorporating the lower body some as well. Plus, the whole body has to work in coordination to maintain technique and stability.

Pull-ups are more targeted in what they do. They’re one of the best upper body exercises that you can incorporate into your workouts, especially for building back and bicep strength and size.

Ultimately, which exercise works best for you will depend on what your exact goals are and what equipment you have available to you. Also, there’s no need to choose at all – utilizing both exercises throughout your training plan (if you’re able to perform both safely) is really the best route to go.

Better For Beginners: Pull-Ups

Rope Climbs are an advanced movement that requires both strength and technique. Oftentimes beginners will find themselves lacking in both of those areas. Combine that with the fact that Rope Climbs can be one of more dangerous exercises in the gym and you can see why I’d suggest that beginners start somewhere else.

Pull-ups are not only one of the best exercises for developing upper-body strength, but the strength gained from Pull-ups will directly translate to helping improve rope climbing ability.

Don’t feel like you’re ready for Rope Climbs or Pull-ups? Here are some Pull-Up alternatives that you may be able to try instead.

More Links and Info

Check out how these exercises compare against some other popular upper-body exercises:

Pull-ups vs Renegade Rows

Lat Pulldowns vs Pull-ups

Share This